From 2cdc315849ac9a079a052b2332a51db537c7e7f0 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Yu Cong Date: Sat, 10 May 2025 14:36:22 +0800 Subject: [PATCH] approx rate for general graph sparsest cut --- main.pdf | Bin 86993 -> 92644 bytes main.tex | 4 + ref.bib | 305 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++-------------------------- 3 files changed, 164 insertions(+), 145 deletions(-) diff --git a/main.pdf b/main.pdf index aed7964b4fad0e96bae36653bed03e84a373f7db..fde243a9667cd3c2e14f15d122b73929145ba207 100644 GIT binary patch delta 18715 zcmZU)Q*fqj(5{^)ww+9D+qRR5Inl({#JOW8?8JDC{k{l2QT{*8av794KWv(T6QjNjU1Ue!VO}v~Xl;EhU1>hOm{P)oJf2Q=&B^_7=V@0gvPfoY)Afxk z020~J(ea8$qVNSa#;;A}^XqLR%E8cxP8v5v0hPDogJXb{Y&Js5gJMjE1dA+Gy0vmH zjO0h{{e^r(YvG%5QS)PMVJNr^BEgwA9oBg^@M3G@?n}010=ZumfeBTTGw*%pV-VX4Dc1*4MKm{o<-j`Zno; zZBpqrA90hrzQS&kX=-H{`iv>J715>kUIras9(Xw-*sT}SN3oz+<3^?f;h%P1Y_m&b zKhAtKey$x0gF_5V3jkibDxEpmvkLTPWtJR~6v$YGzngzVlN0?UA(5cjHGRt6I)4|M zL-{;Sd}GF0=ls#@@l7`V8I1DE_j}7k0QiY{CdJ%W*6aU4=Si;SB{1JSaQL=OQoP1XtalW@uBmg-_jK)W-g>~ zp>JEDJ9>UsqaFI_LDb3a-Lz!cJN7I{p8nvpEoqjSP0wsO|2TZyX5qe>FW+<&*h7b6 z{t$?uY+QP_wE=R-BgJI9T5`=#YrS;sodwywfP3@j0-OYEwX}339QJE*I6KGa!REwUJN$OKmge;d$-J;Ro18}Ks6t7K&Px3 zYwEZar`KTd022w1)g)95ag*P`z~>n%#(dUll`2q&_+oY`++PG8qLpw<|GjYqp~|At zk(16ieaib3JcHCk)GH2*(8ZC;9gf8@ZUiyFgVxlhpw9-Brd%EhW`u^mXQw*VC3eL_ z^+6rM3j~mVzqAs1Dp=6Rb%9$nwyU#H)T5yngmbXAGyg#?X@*&CJCGR$l_s9O(!#cK z8DH;B@mXH2tf1VLWx?BK?iXThj&+#1s75ZU2i<*#g@y!mdy>eQFCxNgZoaVDK!m_L zJJui)G|^gERc<@xXaj%plT+5a|239ah8}CR2pHKvM;!7{`IZOT4wjrxOoqMUP8VSo zWw^sIfrPvvr-0Njx+U+1zIRi#R_P@0uK9yYO$TnbRRj`BY%=CGZjGAEQhm=&ist~o4aLm)A865ia8MbvxkQ9sZZ_VfoK=Y0%j9||C7Rjh^A)xpI8hN z6Yz(J86nKDy$&5j!;q-HlG*&#&g7b9L5PMRf3Rn$+|0q?qVRze~x56{Mk4v;w<%LVg>BIE-u3`cy9J!4W9+k7(Kl zx-gF;9}n_t-nX9C>U-81CrKG4pr@kb_j4#2kn2>puD5=6==1nUO&3TkR_WHzJ*(l|IjY% zf6Ol0BRA4O7IVo8hr^OWm2dG!&dGz<`XaF7?+57x}1*b6H|(=6{x+-5)V4 z8~uhUi&%?>yUBDGL>m+)!g>Zq)NqEWFR~2nWz8eS1547D{7oWs&>DS{I!E($0zWBy8sXZhdrHor z-HPc{L}bE)x(Y83*I5|{?z#803w+i)87+(kDsY4wF$0M zCzY&*%ybi5##tP`s|K>^(-Ee6$TYe( z$YSthYq*tYnr3G)Q;o($9zeY8f7C5W;-g%->a1^~G}+lNpQusx=d~N9!kl{;AkknO z<(t>oEnRF=m_hF2yM?>Y5?F}&qtvdegqc##(ga6xEsB!H{!Y9-@efa2SL!44fVnqz z83~FU*@oo&FvO0C(*$_sav8X2Idg@>j)HoZGBjHar)yqXGY9Z^<|2YaVuShhuWDD* zSjSDgheradd%iz>#z2|@q+oO*2t#^ zLV3%As$Zz451JO2a|oIq5%_ROzuPVIG904~&FsE4=OIttr4r^_^79qG> zdyv4kxPb!~mG4nVeq35rP5KC)_w2w;%lv>G)Y4a};#K0myrTZo3O4^)wRy0ZY+I!O{a_wMo(Tf5({^yjI2h+m!`^_ zfbpq(Z;8qYDqzkC6FmftrSe`}KP~+AaW<1rx|FRS(Ko%3l}Wyhb$~!{Oq;qiszVn@@!&@9%gd8o9o|v_@og=Xiv0M^#-imk$g2Wm=B- ze{W5hB3!hoV7p=Svm4h*4i7ct(R7yWc9-Gy_j3#dUjyoBx{~rxk2)j=3T9Rnr6r>~ zet|*ndCk42Rq42V843(^$>1@)NwLAJBoK*y&{WDyHe@h(X-n=CvesD(in$s^av}N> zSCg)~RNJ4pj1eg91wcbi-ymn%iLB?ZcSykia$~O z#d4v2jorR>$bK*O3L=TYSK~YP=>hH`)7PyoowG~M;;w!Bv((fR%6k-QyzN>>FX`Ym z=lnC6+7LES*x_b!B=fdrS>ntMW${-ffnZs^?Eqb3vT_CH+MQ618bi;n>MD9VpQ&Xt zHKBXTo3TswnZS?rv?4gDS~~H$+;YwNA4N@$FYboHec}?smSSS~FW`}TRhG@Nk*v>W zm*d}}))icfs%Y1|<*lL&`P2|CgwI1l*esTz`F#{=X;BN2T#p#dV&KG$)@ir<4-XZN zoPl(~=licDi%NUwU}rqKeTSjYgohfA=3JkxhP-U_Ocxp_qsn>xt0bKtmkViaN?3P9 z)ZimvU;Hth2e#Z%m%bgLY{&|GvaSX0K)QveTe|9NRD9xjmz9V=YmTaMBlQ4(^J?if zn(zMa=}*i4rRHVQj-n~lEkjP;F1|Y>IUu~^&*~9UkLS7#%BoI|5kqeoA=SztzqYpVt`r zG&(Cf9UUT1N7o%PM^>ZM_KM@LrG%z+X;wJ~Ym~)wC$Gy#P)qUBut;zdP%&bg9BpURpn0*zmdxtybuRfEd=m zy4@#=FvmV0HB`xd7r^scs_i^tV1{)?$BabL!j1%?Rl7U*EurQ-NbVp(1yuv&d~)#N zhPb@ySi!s!N9K`^%!k3|k!qn<{gKg<@T#Vbqi^9Ih$VkvU`Z`=5tIpovYnPKu2y0yfM5b}`7B%-DQ^mlS zb>gcsZuBXN!F>ZwgO#ct(D-_QOr*b**>Js+CQs*hL2P_Cw!GU{!0gZioOdM0B|erK zO8sj@BgA~p@-y@ppd4`}<4u?GE}%;@8+T_)hM*WsyY(w2d;WF8juH&{m%{aHbLRE4 zbY)x5@fp{lzxk}T0NbpcsfR$<&XQMzd-CpOT;>y`cm67FT${oIsD=<&gQN#^ds}o# z0+*}JNXFxn~^g4Q7_!^j4CK_=)2@ z+(O#hEAQO9ce0d#a5kOk2NKFx;~M3S9@5fsmuJ{3>~h(B>jg|?8ubbl$NRgx7=jPF zjl<7G5T-h4ehJMQB~;A}b=Umzy3T0cl9d7SF}J%bQuIYP2Hq47Ur&;y<-E76-Sd2# zyhuX2_Zb6>IbN&vGK+4{0%~KJdVnXd+d4E7!wgL}PBa=w<5TRrt!}l;to}pH?wnjyQ!(&Rv(KE^QDpFkF6Ai?8PxZ) zJMp|m8#NlBJy?2jQ~Ve}+el$ShQlA?k5A=@OQo@d=>f^82$*1-E?cfo7w+#adkE`w)-D)NJQO%N}N?dhah3&PW%B*2XyP`xNPvC z`_0tOZis1+1_hD8Y1!HF{!XknwJ0I8Xe~)7XG{~LP>>ND92|XrwIfWTp^he3p6UsQ z#J6bdy{gsoXvx@H%e3&=f4Mtbi&_c(%N}?@QTTFkc8@qphC?#U&NgwvFi186mu{fZ z7<-b+I}>N?>dSnLHbu*)15BuLYS>Js9=C+$$*;NDFzW4i(ZAib6L&DTRk_t8C%BMD zHP>_*)w5RUOlXGu!}cvsIj`Fa)7_b1llj^Gz+C&YT7&oN@@(^)P?lgRtL&W)oktez z+0559FDc@<@PX$LuJ~xCqUn_@CBH$fQ8k71r4(1SHU9>B*$MwnHDL3_FlD#MDYtcI z*7|6w8M9fX$J{eF--}t&vD|#2P-u2K%Gg|`UW)G?yqbfp&U~Z&kNBfpiRpt(>z+X} zrbLYby?&P2L4PD)@x}pNHlEj*m&J&b_r}y>8)C`ZHW4g26O=UpdVb zT=+2Dr+}k)RTkZq2{`}3_2kDJX$3AP&nsmSHO#*;j=C2SuFBJph}y*QYDwgjL9!YV z7aUft*3kPeDuTQ|ssEGV;(qTVRp*;uI+BA!u8v}V`LaPP@9PoO&(Z=4(?*Ud zQ!4b@0vxqB=4+ESG24u#0GKcN6}MDEFu1MTAETOJDU4Ee3IGPtvCfr46Ik*bL#t&M zV{wQy)$H5sOG~_O>yLn2odxof_UlKJfbHoB5nsxu;NEGtK^lgeA3q@a1}cbLXW!^# za9*YS)}~wg{g8(>=~(jbB!K}h6m;*P;l6Q?|b0ifQrm2lX2SUS)0sa3@`w&YjF zx*UD+6<4v9x~*X@Sa&fkiOAxX=t9eOz!0sHd3m?ZO>Uk^sLLHEO@B?uy|46ksAw(2 zKyVaX*Y9_ZzU0BMDcC1(Fokn7i1@%_?8Ybztsa%-vS=sk+TatG~AA;~s@AYb@9S!p<%k%4H(?j*D4WWlr zz3wB7uG(CnS7Zy1Fy54j?wc)&?p5OXzJo$c3ns!iUg?HuLW> zT#yhG{LLS0ym#lz+|;}6-tgUjdtUFO`{*!SB93`crScjm@#RSx)KR2dQ#zrO&DI^) zLuKFVUW((Z5yO0#wQM{K83H#c8)_{H5p^#tv$nS8+9oqwE2x>ovLD*#J@KXpfDAsDU^C7B8VjmCc8AZO^E(u`=-o zksr-zXt;YgaMLa(jU}ZcX~*C9 z9`czDz7tC5_{R*6l9^J987W&)r9ev2_lX%XGB3mwR3>OhnKtjlxEpQW5uOMSF_}04 zBV8B^Fvyk}NFIf!L(!So2F5#ymVbwbN14B5B?V^hdj0+pD+k`i8wZh3G=Rk%bnM9J ziObM>EjaL{LKo|dIS44jpgj}a*!``3@bthvjKLbJJ&gHPi}+!I{2=MR#08j!C9xC3 zq`21U;a-qYyXvDD4{(iyfa4w@K>c<#L%F*TL(2*-P0sl#+|a(j?E-G?8HhK2EyVwtyyOkqWOy%+jh0ex> z5Da7FW(P2JMH~1oNqHsV8i~-UYxt5_j3F45t>TEDDz|a|*!sfOodDy2W9ls2SSY6K zPcoUn&O_3l@IGmxB4l-r@_rbsa1hf3Ob$;E-_c8j#!SR4&pPi0jhtEJ>>V5gr6_{y z2c7Qt4>@+L-*vQZKKM00YzqGkv3+G}Q(6Am`siGL7InNVZHyMv3r0L3wDdkd7rGYz zI2NO={W3Kym@ ziU|+v+wDwgcIAZfKASq9H&}nHr{VrIXS3x2c4q*Z=*iWWiUJxBCzRJCj5VrD&3I`RK6HnH{oc400y+ z{k|kb4{>S`*} zRh*Wp_o1jyK#0jMa7+*P(e$dW#=g-`{`w6+fO;rIDhYY`b4xuA zUqxx$Nhi=S;2(itBnwtfxwC6X5|Byxg^R8%mog?~DT_Ub*G-2@o;6_668ms{)HlJF zGW><676yD(ax9O4@<{n-QR9bn@Z;KwNAnuK35JeXk&AO)4lK%RQQ(ux<{2LM<-bXx zXmr{bWD*!uK@`=z8;YA?uDJt9F`pXWf*M2O-v(W|qw%5*anznkcP(kQ29BMOndY5} zE8}(sqdvG@^^|xDX6yQy_dv{p#GJ_VLKQ`(ReCB6WT0pGLAba}8m!=sc)g=6!Rplq zf4W4Ds0C6^uNQm>9Vnd4kEy1%#eb=7TPf=oK*+92E?C5%yj>^1A2ABMTs?i3bnso8 zi%8!*nYF|0=~CktDEtol@%0~d6083|7VSO+kQvTr~!IHdT-3E}H? z^SA=);YC0}9b_|Hsgk8Q3miL_C?`iF6@s{s7&0mu@@$2gYTzn1GGsRuo)K!OVlp0L=taC{AO!0%+CL4p?RHTi zGeGIeI1qq;LQWofiyLflZD|(be!}E+CRk*GE;P`16Mg(i$r#9G4>kjdkp?(eFGk0>GYlc6JmuTj~ua< zO9U7e>e~zlm2gzb2>f=`pT7Zz)}@dtCe01s7h&hP)*cZ{93>vSS8R@T0%8Ig{l#Zq zYK}T>C0lX9Lk(>{Q=fUa@NF3JxX>;0G%5)@z@v0m;2WJE^y&S=cVqkRAZyR2iH^i( z->I9R*H~Uhsn@-8xFatsczA@c*CNLJ$^juwGH-IfiYQ|>O|^2v@LYiC{Q++QruPP~ zarYZ>iI3$o%dz-y7#cCQ5ALJ;#OKw+@RJnwad$Scjx}-4jq!42`cuU{k+eQQ{3v+hQOnStMi{3PSm4!l*V;I0Zb1YE3iRW zcu%A?$NwaaoqFUq+x^s?x}2Ti@XNLSG!!cdpemQP1=Dh znmYBPGhcPyF-9pPmzBZFa}AsUMkiG>QhCiO3t35P%w>iWf}5@q48f|NUeLu)r|qWW z>xt7;(Z`C6*htSP)ogQMYTK;V3H)#AX07$o<$OzdWWKI1oM7y!IxakDga z|M3QKq9iU=gY)Z`rvA(wEkhPwu@AqlH^?j|CCB9+9@A4+W&j2Xii{M3we`Cy`LJ$r z(E*9F6ttv!;j1Yt(|vEZ&xegrXV2tuq2Q}*ysgUue1a@npaCJeYF}Kl=bXGl`lV;N zpv5+Y=-gE(N7rQS$O~R!I)Lpq6?FUvgYZ*X_jCo(Ro>%8eF)o4nog}~qpMZjt zLRx|Wt0kZV56corL#(eX8x8jSn^r-Lsn+*Xx=7cgVOoZ2e1jz>3b@;EC@--{9B!ix zTl%RQ^XF&-58QCw)ZdY)p7wFKAO)_=+i=&O;u-in-%%L--kV-3bXCtWX<6BU^EoI=UTOh5u=0xrdg-qB z*QBZ@wf?`gPsm~tMnD;{g8ljxgXX3imu|GKBgpwrt%CK*zidUL3BOFO!9?&uM6Q2F z)nh`~D^qqA&Qa!0f8C-iil2FMB)|PQi&G7Y=X0%b2|eH3z8iZy1g>LUHw7|pI!O?K8XrIcFUrbykGA7Z`-7lbFaT~ zsjOPI37G9lF{;$S4uV#e0p@~a_c6)uRZNdRxGcO$A4<@ZMsZlEJrH@UMoJ?!w=Crl z=bOlu9=y}kib4Vt7LA^621<7&SwAlDzTNZxUD*}URF9s4%97OGqiGbw5k>YWwj}6? z8m<}-7+!7!e171#vFmdjFM&rmE>1@6R}gZhdIzUBxq8fLvP9tJdD_#A)5!8Y(q!MU zWqiwed1WKUxtBH2Fl6a5k7XFJf|9QOcFaIFCW@B7D9Rg7h*h8f&yG9?u@pNBTj`48 zt{tS|Ca{`Fbf_;gc?GF1a7<*m%~c@p@Y?7 zdP8w=i3Eu~@@C*T3l7{>wI?|7+n{7|P>`p|0Gmibp1jCB`5DM;(j?(UjgPr|3-m3` zFA3Ro)ay_f2s0reZ$m}tzGqTl=F+7VXOHpcO(BemL~NhJQ46=s@3}}qwHqh(1JX>S z`=^({bKCkSWp1~=!rdvyupkwcgBh$>3=P%kq$nEcK3@S*JUJzX%>5oJsV(hq)DgK2 zzl8z*2)<}ko&s4Iu%Yt+ZV)eZOd$j~S;Kr@Lc_Rx;icE4dQzDRvVXX2%>6(@e55c6 z`uLD!yEtL9YhDNe|H6wDH_{Sm+9Ysza1kdi9Z8wy~PLPpzl`=zLcHgNHJ* zaWKCQLv8oHS#ET;4Gcc7A=ydW#SIV?CBVoMF`Oc3!=KVEAY_m9lX*i~e@*r=7UlZ+ zX~Aq^@=Vxlt&Gl$vv;horD6+H1L_HDesP{VOU_D5eMy zwYJ}t;+C$g+ts&a+(N2`rp;#6BmeB*ckTM9(C=-4b)=^Xzgku?+GgV zO=53MEvrIv{H}DK$c>HQZkW{7zHSL@WD_2}X^fB72;%#CUw%J-Xd51F(*I;P;P&{E zb61*hX%ujuxG&DSow!flJo~)s&^cSGN>>Pz$OmtDL&dTXOO66dJ_S-Ie!X7 z?ufMR#qM^@M7}XmrCH&%MQD5%-pU_4$lqds(uJ+d$b8uBJCn!@um4y@_oUyRZ$-vf z&Il{~w%=V7rTb&@-r4K>q!}+!p$EN%^K~{*C-KM2RdqNxG+`lzjx}=xp^X)ST!n&+36NH zLKmCvyEiPPp5e0*Gi?;J)aiM^A5 z?q;YR%LK)gqUiXt<6mh1Xfnowvwwc8UGi90Oc4MG)+Lj6ZMJv16RWyD! zb@5tCb30C5S#fvC5cJu&Cu;1{yh4Y5fg{Z(U;Tf3;M7b;5Pa%3H3+@YoZN~wwTKaf z(YUWrE|qG*{vYKe>hYy+@cc)J)9$dT`NIEE%CaA9s+c4Q1D%zGhlA_?N@_L|RyK~r z*kc?JTcY8A!a7FPn`iNbNGMA)T8UAK;q=xG8_9emTK-buaJ>zAKoqB%^*%G5*fjK( zz}&Sd(}buYiQ0B;y!b?b3D0vgaip0-?tI=U-CBbloo}4;c(jGP6Uh4N$=!JC$$h%# z64}|DH^mh^1 zd0a`?frtbIPX!q;RAk82@B037As&d~b$DTPhtA!n@igS)x4oSh$0HT%wli~~qqY#tSL-p{1{090iMggjO2A_Pj`i_f`D-*70 zsBG%T{3jLpJ`T)jk(uh59NZ5Q6OtVbS?)IKCMIQPs7wyT04^N?Nfs|bf!_Zb^c*${ zfQ8Z?ZGPOiFcofE<+?7A^Mn(pJ?q$xbzt-4e!n!CUt&Eq6~6 z<6Ety>d6yiQ6M)rhHH;jXp0wI{ed6wSdBI)yldVOMowEy2lH)Onq!*Z7H0z5*zQ7NU9SWW@T6z76lZj_3{D$OB`txeuuit3zUYkVo zNnLF79^1$pzmhA7{uE(%QLAZm7~*k44s)K5w`%M=*JR_PN`9L&Fl+9q;#6@4!W#(m zlpNWu>{Q9CWPc|MX4Aw|SlfR=d)`u!^;RC!{}qU^F7bPCdzpS?UmGEsZ*`HZw@{Yb z&S*J1&RSQqdXv>?g34MAjOf4g>5ZgM=>vsLBJUn06%*;9XReVwAT z=)_}$YsZw-%r3v0R~2h4x7XP2>ioC!>%kXbHy!QM`%ZFyW4gwlJZOOd9DcW%C}E8X z6pc7;-S=IaPDo?@Tp57j5Y~Aq^Qm*p@j5XvoVCi0n=re#hBBu<)_o02)H@?2xPSWHtQR7sp6&YWL|C^U)pc3mB1T9pje`ryP z^7mMLF31+!Rn}15O-|4;)UFTA9j$HH%BK0uyIf7u&2d4|cP?sM_=S}G;zQ*1x-+>7 zS)9G=PqtiI_u)+L9cbmDZEvuEV_yNsxxQXZs%g;v|ld~c;o zt+?uOD!TX=*7DwWXP?+{BT-tu=Q(U}*`{n>2~*?xSj(^~%YL=_=g$EJHV~uFk=MoF zm(B#sb%}ME`#Z1}ht`ewg7=5Y*QZmJlMXdg#1af zABp!=NQQL2n!*=%K*Gw#Lm9k#SKBPF6@sA8kAug&u9G1Kv?!Owb%%z?bJg08-G|r> z=(FPCoY96YetG^TG65asC*@S)$mka9wC6o@q~V%^GTS7+3@yC$1n%kA`m&-r>G&Og z;&4Bf!F7#OE{%lOHF0NM7c60SF#d#|hr=JuR`EY-EK)SWBY0>v({B#X%sO#aS=rfr#(GFRw9oQR}u?fiU-L-ej5=nlv_qRC%bI;)To;%=~*!c)DRv3aQb z<1R?3BJI2Q3#F#{@+krG1En@Afj$wmg8|OTkvOM-k&1)`LT=>VVTT3hmED^2OgY@?SBF^UY7s2*!ph@bF%X$l1yWPvvMT%FVh0a zs@^2(o&?KO)@9KgA&!R)k;b9M(Xf=6HostHohAv{!%Rcd*{kOw$2db?$^NS5!@U%! zij6Z)jB-cn%X6*B&| z=?M0{1ZyY+kKz5Q+kS+)Ev@ESA|Bu<`rr;p{V^0w0|ma9TJiv~l3_ex ze}ciJNWjCZ#2E04I`v00!bpA_`OBQn^z~hJ_qF!*tt9p321rVMm4Kl8V1f2XOS=hz zEt0f;2~f4e{={i51cMGDq^|BL`bcwV5NQWS^n98>bGT!E?epibE9_)o)~ddT(IelCBFKi!~KbHK<$&1hqZ87B55HVHxQ(|ndBBpgO6dGMtpxT@qicdzp4{oiv#-Z~8yP{hj!tfBL zkCOt^_aAQq1ySNEEE0pR&5c(4O3&H7X`$G5f4mld{{1wvp1g7)UodFq2N*sjvvN#j z6CL;tDLmU-4zZZpbO2m*_k~K!Wlz#R$aj=5j~6@1laiKe5?Sw@Ww52Lk={~6i-L0M zz9JEmSjh(9g*wXZy#TpQZuREJ=V#w*9P@Ow22u8V0wZHAvyqdkq2mse%i|cfBm;$z ztU$7pOad7L`nK$+j0-U_OW03SsipcLw>m4+y))t&ZNr=bZ9twQrXscdL%m$3`7=F_ zA!aN6p!{Bx7iW)4`0B@-I6eTD<5^Lxz&J5c?_DN_oW$o`rnff9iQz#1p()w>^D65& zyXt{}a*oRQlF{NNtnY$cRrdR>EEK`JVQ}tm13aR!7QG;)my0@EA5vP&%kOb9@$(*V z>kGKwui>SOC;`IzI8Hp?gMS7l>iU4QTHQ`FzS6jzBP(n6(N$pmyx6ByYcV>vuXKd)>E|EY zB4ApZzz1uDVkVcT`tGQSV&cLP9(Sv?S#9KJTmHc#IIv7*_sb7oh<(?tS$=eetWCRY zL64k;)~P-l3s7A*PxiH(XM5YogkxEcCNbk&9S_ai`P~@ed$=O+c$o|X8$@sU+vrpnOV6U1rys1kqRIMxQvzwX{ zs~%jm3NUtcd_Tq8;>$US68!e3a^5^~+KBRyZ&9Iv9Kp$DcB#x1X$0lyUKWjDlepY$ zoSixr2QgLkda8X=d8&ERM)r4SDK%Aw>Biq~epno=9RRk$o9{f@2VOQYW=~K>u8qx= zORP6ze+g8OPKSMFLiqGBC5se88{Yi-zoSWDx|>nWcHl9Jtfko%9RknB*{-C2z( zokf{3-Z7Knbt&|cq>bkBJN?R=Zr^8g;aa9)4NZ=9b2XVeo+RFB+~bm=F8N8v^Jab} z3Si(csxy}?SW->16Byk#OIT4GX4B}pz)h(oWPgH_^RCbNc7K^^zK&uS_h!$__03H8 zNeSADrV0&3FTDxPTli64758rn{;#}Oq`AZ7=vh4#!9`sP4!7xtNfJTDwek#%TrZ_O zbK(31p)04oA}6R0?|k2xG3~C|Z;_!4(STv+S@N#CW-TuEkQ3wD#tK|kgDlptNJ!XoRNRX3auA(Q>9MY zY%fWRd1u3gC&duu`K@G~e*X**lvcMGZLe#|Zd;JCuHqfka$K(_7rg+2VRbIO?|}ZH z^e{Cw_Xy^8F*NJtouQ--b?f?{VJ`}$J|sA)P=}R;R(p3uRbmUfSiJdvXXRbmSSC9^ zPXDqV&1zT|;~Q({h)^tFk1@B=MKvZT`W#xxd0dGvB>xaB)&0-T{W`ht&=2F2tcYI9 zBn+`?y~#A&PEWwVv3(`vMfhV5M*!3lMhz$vznq3m44e9@?_{-3$w1?|GVXk_$X>+TqydOim`zRtxT{zyGqhhN0HXyQV zsozOvIThp&A^W%FQBt*D%Rr!*f={`KgQ^IxvUlo%qqZrFuOzFBv}f|g;|qAqOMu%s zT65RYGexda?~`sJtUX!rs6;2e@r5_^q0TnsuBe><>L`gKKc+Tc<~}LJqpfbfN8ZOs zLdLdqi5oi%tGOCbAy7<|VJ99KywxIZsjfA8=TUdEr#KLspR|698|9ae$n~1|1ASm` z>EZc4E8ypR(R?Suv~DNR#%zam-5L>SbD2Dl!;0Zid$j&XSbg7sH%$25hJmTFl&e9c zdU-tNRN26f_pi3hKgDI?T(*$at3;9<>R8ELIs(Nn z-y+@#rg8|A<&Luw#?1tzB&@)!6{We#CXN>djq3gpoTG{(2{Rx708n$ z@XpNH)28#ny9bOZh}r0Pe=_wvUfS{19Gwh(r=rXS$!TUp zrF$zh)29NWAW~3GYQ884U;k0ybX>Y*jODMN@+^134>^+&nkU@%Xbv&|*z#1BF;q3? z@;JunE@*G`M3kBRjnsVRfQ67ZN8yg)V!N&K5_xfHtgxo0Bfr{=4pFR+6EWm32oLX> zAiz+L&*OiEFgHtUHw&l&9GsiA)ruWN^B=IaCUSygAi%lVTeo;X)&BuU>wg~z>p$RZ zEffZY{a3@)${+^9{x8GbDj^BlfdJ>>PNkFu1wylOu(PwWrdG>>zWraGl?A1Ov+*S2 zzY^eaa>6r9SvkA7l5lYG{@+a&2|GK_|4Qd!T`Px;Htdfp!~R%CXt*aN8fcky^H)Aa zwW9MT8t~!o-==spttagGdOx$}X_5a@#;`lw#Hl3F+}&-vXsxHPvGo^4GRROh8<7?y zDnP~lV5R5qnhGr5uG_WDFq;qeCs1J9-i1aXjSN_fr=^7IE+z0nF_AO=J*N=0>u3t3 zbIHxCmK64dQn3{ZNLBqDDI%DPcJVM{WG7t@Xv)zkptJj_DUAwAzg$c(WlO=8Wu`>C zzsPDa&*B2o*f(ebYArQIA^JJUV2#DDs^+AkY~2Zq$sOoc zsWbHo5BzyT1Qr%`y0>Bo^S;zX)WbyZ7;&qmjEoDY{ouT~2dfqGWc>AU+)oYAUobIh ze;o%6ZoJc7y;uZqG*@j^cjG*jn(fzwiB3EstICiLGvy`8%`r`1%VAe}e^8?5K+nP;z47R$9GxU(viOsz!2LDW0+^5KQYyV_}qGr_=w*ch3f z3&Nu1=5K(HAYf*pH?5Y?cTEFup!%%vBG&ky2-c}S113nea8JkuGIt40p@(o8t_a*9 zNeqE0v?d!wNLBfMx`JJegh~ttgHrG*o7(E0YZKGUtoNLnyC0AF-(<@RLw{a2&*Z~7 zYk>@EbM#YQm@uaQ)bS3$BU(hV1NFyNqHRg`c-EipQQ53NS7XHFl3Zfo+fDc z?J8L}AmdHRu|BtK-tjhsRzPy9iLTj>IKAM}#6eWu-~AL{Q%53UtDJ*w+rV}aP-Y?C z5oE`cffGV;mJ+QiR~ToUAW93VExI5^@)@+!RE##%M(zwM62&xEydbc}&MJ=ihV~$| zmjKsslwn+2D0gPq)6x$Vb{|oR?G-_d^b^;X7onxe2&uW6&*E=fj%=lKL+Ltnp#2$Y zQgU6%?EEYIS9WG`%pjlVoJOa=9;tBAH1527ZrwjC=jb5aOZ?90(*VCZUy7q9Q}j;s z6#_pE13Vu*NpxXXN2MotjpWISmXFN<;RcwNmL2(D zW4OoPz(|$V3ee#LNYjYMKLfxjDn)n-N^a6j#W$$G@eCxfjOZ`gqwzWQtpxn0bgfJA zDCrqQ*GT20jS)Grw=gPKj3TdKTy(wxe+Z7pJ`5`I&0N+N^RH7a&w(f%0$D;x6PwEQ zi*33t8@@@{KkWnNPeRSW(v_R7-4C_Apuecr!K@5(7!D%94A^(-ak+jNc$o&eTC1-( zFN=e#31p})fI1FUw=W`aR?L^Q|`H9BpPn$@FVg}0cp{?Bt@-k&si^Saa zcq%HNU9As+3#%p0^gP`jOE(h5jyUY~A&667Nv*Y`cnWxR$cm>GKT%1BY_RGnSkJm`w_4qgk={fE`FZ}cU@UGkzd23?}5r5Q|Ged z%r9oFjMN8r@(bIFR@{C%N|mqC$}iE}UA(y|lny;BKGVIo*C=}RD0DY+A#lHCU9me5 zvS50zbkO<(eevWGMKuf$1Q^bsr`nwfS5<{E=eKEQ^us|fePze)HX5)m9YG=-HOqWki_#cRUS4|hjepd31h^wZ-)=2|?u7QoK5HCPq z+Gs4uDBJ!X`Lzq&_fA-Ctu(Gl&Gdc~_I-MfRhX$3TBgT`@6>E6ZA=)$WHeQt6MevB ze2q+T&bM--R{TE!l?ZD0lb#PV4ZrJL=URhhrlt)(^mCo`RMFhH(MF`*Hb_5ty7%Gv z@h_v(*<^0YwEzpYBbDqji;p+x_M9jfb%U+gf8ar41FZ8&WuD6Yz8qm2ISvn=zy0{W zmBXI?13AP$lEUr>-;=_MZKQbq?#=6GzyESrH0PL5jV3#fpY0r%qd5Y>4vn__>`1Xm zLS^WDuVyRny^*(wMv0eBx!#$7MYQtk zf4mrPaL4g{))#uKaJK*Q@aWa!4MIP?YRbtBVRw`0J3x3xYeA(aYRYIb&ANUf%fp+q zYI_W(#aT5h#;4Ut^4T0wjPgNKUNwE`w+b=)ACHcYjyFjE`p3m-J-$WjQqu?7%23Ik zr*P-{DSUJE$-??(!Hem%{@yD4v>5(1e;ZShJw^IGofg9~*+aT(r(oa$JMjwGOlRdV zWzBIpnAxM~2EeMCkUfvRMq{zJn@xRa)7@#cdTB-+lb> z?)MKHaOr~L&*S5crT{6s0I9deN!|cubD%;F)LA)h3O;V7SSR>)@$$*b!-H41e`JJq zv~{Dsje>j6cIYrFRr@7P7D7x6Jx{XXAKA(A>FH@--Zi1}>10@+Rg)2Rs=jcFpEftM9`bUexr2~=l21B zQDhJAtFz{OmcErtQ{U8YClz!{dUwl1dV}TP#^Xv|x5T5B%REYLGbYp1e>Imnu5#&D zxYXNox#^g{45(ga)`*-}I;|{tZS%&$Rnm8_E8K_edEKhUTt<6E0NE2j-0-i~U>&#T z_HOm!GMn~RoSn>IwkvFUu|1pHRCvqG`ekNA-zZeZtz6|+-hIikw|R;x_g?U~;EiO@2_EAB)Nlqo-VCw~`+-94h#J*u{4h*vEomm}n2 z=vAiuD$}ouQ8`1YR?opA4DI*o3^i99Qdn$%t|C?PhowT|Xx@xbe;ds@Zdm8q#0*ni zo@&XO#li|_0d}1P_L%B`eMMDUlYZ9IK2OVU^qZcX+jgm4ELFEH?fmy8{ia5RHFV@P z9T{$+V{$TU*pYrg#`MUTjEGcg7V5=9v2kI@c9(9I$O1;Ujzqg`&E5+L<$B3mX+>se z*PJBPcARvo-O<;?f9Yfb%X#pm9`3wu;E)elo5a|IVbzqoFwk*1y_nVYUnfc^^AMtk z?EQ;sQWfKq7xm<Lff7L8Wbj!le%RqEf$Hhfc z3{Q&7%V~X8(Pt-v370jLOM;wqVKj-qH~W>bRJXn~F|Th=|P( zQb`0Mw~W-!e?`6n-St3{5`QZ$_vXl;lNgB8T$k6FodC3x2@Zxcn$d=@2bYL(yAt;3 zvS&pTWHz85QXc3AruFH#yr4zx$$Ul16@IccD-v`c1`)aT*MN%=;v)8kz=v9z1>;to z+Gq3A1vR3#ZkUM5Wv(+GmS?Z>o4+Sq>gc^3NKS>dSxInI5`S0S0Gz4ATuB_T?#K!Z*O!U zF*r6LFd$M2FG+4@Zy+%^Hy|(|QVK6gL?Bx{F*8L%G(s{#LqbG1IYu=^L^MJ%HbpWv zLq^UhP3Lwo{3#kx_V3MPVfK>9hSs#zTZ=&) z${+#dPytD(gerIl)ldUZpb4JBGw`>08{VHco>GaX{cVq+mabAjDWjD6gU2L_nqQdT z5aq2A{HfoNzwHZb!zN^43Uwjq@D2U(fl)t9!w!6c&#(boum`g+4~wt_%di5gutrfY|4yah($hM;hdEe) z5AacS{g9s+yJqZ~v0=uB8GB{ym9b66K#i3$7Rgv7V|}bhWnkE=6szo0waTgvGc(AVIX}H$ovk>90%rp1Qt62%NZ}g5*p(+#%+w-7`HKQW8B8Ltxt8W gIsEM)A^!nz!&0P|sZ#+Q3^_45GBXM#B}Gq03VTlR@c;k- delta 13231 zcmajGQ*dBml}>^JA1b}C#%lFLaUlr)d|G>( z*7(<|rAxI=!^-ROY3sVd&0+?qaV+0#9Z?>VgckWo6zfSOZui8QGcE%J+e_53f1{>j z^?4cS?1Tg0Km4>11>DW%6B!&*Hn!Q;9_w4ZV7}{=8nQb46HL}BWmv7uWOYD0vt7xY zvRo(BYHz3L;KFnN40C{6A|kl!@pd@-(;qji_SLQKiJ8fIiLB8*XIT$o$*KW7xbr}l zf10Vb$%JsqZB7=6DVnj$4~mvd{lKS8v5)d=3;b&RV-3F;r#G)p59bL)a4c(uK)$11|e3Ps}OHgZV3|{dGH(Mj^A( zRSRc0z1IvzQSjkhOkx`3FHIJsltgxvh)2yS3)5Ql^gxIB4-z?SnEtdr0C%;jYvp{T z+i1hOTeIc%vpC?FW;YXVYCyYvxZt@|+a1N0H^y@x_|{ZKbf^HYa0HATZ&}C&sjCkI zD^RdA*HQkYl6J13asJN{yX+N<=NxVmN&;QEP$KrqoFEg4WRVIa%WHTG88K&K5IUNI zzK>@Y-kQr!+P6!gQEhvY6M$bRCYgzcfDtxTISY(qQI-6Z|BOTIlRBj`AD3$pQWYaw z5nbE~6mt#*NNvSzve2> z?YN>ei;0O&!M*CdfhzYd@m6gmMU1(l`Xg~%y!n(${pn1!JA!AB#F;df(a zZD<`&7o@Yh|VQim#U$7#mKxg8(mlZmnu!8W`SDz3CVz5UkJXhjP&bL^_#k|i&{FU$eYPr`V<4`{u z-YI}%yV46FB{pMEmU0m`6s%Jg?#S*_3DboRxr(!#@7fnt!;luU8ON$aB@U^Ro);~lYDZVwzD~#Jb0TN zU7S<;*8tYg6d|l_bcmlt0t>l=p2i|X4oQ$yPc+6LJd@$j?I7e+8pWiWD~VIbp~C{^ zDW<@wIZ=}UO zCewCWXVo8UiDs>17)k-%uCCU_*k)vNI(80(2Uj`i1%qrYx2s7LZug-9k*F%GDk2Ij=_91wgH zZ!?0ROHh|lq_1OMqwc(;?y)G4#T5O6J!f5RI_K>nYQft*-vuP7f{i z4J!7bzOXO(KDh9U5I;orF?92udq6^0ZLREV6r=5Qu<>l(-O7OGgk$p%y=NAruJ08t zOTd5iY5Emf;nAWRN?Y$Ybr!fedJv{CAp!+s^+&CQm=gvHHMM*wpM*4TZQBW4HuV!6 zR#)kKXm?NSh}Q9djfcL!#R_D?d^F>XtEBXBqUJR|P%C7mq&$F^w)#9cdkn3mMaQ&% z#q)yN9p`oN=Q#vkmOy%jA7p^UiFy{NZ@pCvs1Vl3s44!;_FrBZFLkt6gvd`Wb8I2o z-}A)*cLu+up2r;s1iD`^zeb`ksW|tQV zTcGn0;2cjy-?An|(HaEd&YGiY$KtBg4ihejD}vj2Jh3C?czB!W?3sy0nCDbW4&c-5 z^(#2G&>?eAg6ZOUlW2Hmv8=$=1l*g|pG=#!K9)t$*Dc(P#Vmz)VC|$rwb~Wovv9hbS~A5&i_pDn#Ev=Zqr(>R5gm zuWhXU@~HZKl`}43;_8m4#(AJz0PZvEO(Ugqua0ad=7;=COff%>- z8-e~X)mdH)!Ubw9?@H0T20G${NPMwf>CzQHqdbnuot`K^T-ew}cZ7qKa6z&&Ts_!7 zY?rDKZF(UA;W3a^V0&OREaD8%d6VcDG2XyE2_2EeD&Ge}B%!{FM9(0j!NzW30ZVas z`MBE1Y=CF|Y#Fci8u+n?UB%b%OCyPKHjfusStJ(#e6WcwDdjltqg~)((7K!Jp#3f z96qXn_U&6qZHix$@DDZIo`>Z@7pt4geI&HmAGp=ZtIdv`a4l6b;?sUSTf9VE#>a1V z#U$nxfb#I(D{w3F-E}EDk$1FxL(OZ>`!$Ia%Ei+DZ*cdGb6-7bD$>(OF@Monl(C3H8`O zE&{{6=ZW@kPlND!S>sJ@vXAK4{SL_R336m5O_L6Qd~}MD!n(?s6i1HQe~S?SA?VfM zfQajyd<%oe{F$h0O$Dmsndz_B+MC3jHl0f&RBf0Np4>fE$QE{HOEOt=)Q|DIV(jp%Ei1ll2|7l_ve=1Q<)@=^8f zA)mab~;i{Mt}C!TaUhn6^%cr{(?Fmultj= z9cSR?OUZMY0Oba0CpRe1-fhekdgB5FTI?4^x3XICZaYiOo_Hp59E1W4_^Iew`&(u=Ru1%&J79-M#lh7q{q*xQP`XgsSB-#u3VI3+3t(O*e(7XId1x}qs2gRB{|tqV^*qGV&oz@7yDrSgu=tw8;2wVPwUv=^ zsQR_d{u}&@mH%QS6RESM)^4lLLo`GaF}Nqg_w)zz!!ij$sS7CeEV#Y!Wc=1%w|IFj z{z34SW`^mAUt$#tfdj1@0`+(KSgKo1Nel*FtI-Z_b>O~Yk5U^vr|M}_9+}W2-&?Z> zqxnh;OLs^R`K>S>o2HZQ45!TBvTM@C*_NNshY35rQCktuDtKr6?tvJ7;L$3VT;i&z zgL9kDb&+Ehn_#d{J8$mI;4TYL!4C*=_IZ_r_b`wQun|7J-@LxvFi17fX6`!= zCEdd#b|sGa;L5V9wro8HBe{AlhWbEIuQ-^!S2-7F86g`~25QjTyxUH-(~p%rV}D0{xWWgNjhsjR1uf8TnRuPlWnCMYC|6g~8lZ~6>f5>Usz|L(+8uy=YuQ;hhsr0`YLGJAkX4O{d^PYg~VyB%=TX3v3jfP-j<}L+NrmB0o z+;8V>`aO<94je-o!?M(=+dlY2xy0|xu$Lsg625uOOj|f(yd_<8B>MqL1e0MFqeHWjy9s2QgR;?*;00ZiDDg;iYP>C0kkaqLQBX6 zlW0QN=*3i#Ic&QDIFe+xd)P0JkEI`ucORDlF%!!WwM1O0$hCs4V$e^H6+%wmM$|$% zxJN<&h6bSul8tT%g9UDkU?0(BI0|rEU_Phf+|?+0BiC$!Or(F5;|OAEgA}pg{$VQG zk3dUxblZpSa_bPytFM0o`wbDCAh|4dpY!Hh2b}~!8I$g#G4T^4oQuQ_X?YCWaKSG| zw~!!ezzK<1M2{^H-a_I)2dHlKQ%DV+nMR1a+Cp5z2&EI@GRXQbpx3^D?XjtA5*LYU za3dhv6Mf)eObbekXF!$x|K7j*CDxOkr+bW$SnM<(RaBn?S*|U=-d1-zMN%8vw(?ER z*l;u$_!$ToY#By0rz-Jlx3#NV7ya^4*+qW*bX%6KfB25mh?8k0)uFo=HJGaTG0t_< zOXws_QafK0Jb&H!D3RG#sJ4*Jbj_T=2;a^QMr~2) zYURmiw6`nDtYn9X4$;nhKM`B59g^9A^lYZQucOl6V>3f*Q7i-e17 zGh5ki&PT}(7o}3M%D&35%D+myhEqjrAPR;|n?Wl&Mp<(k*>~+g7wXw8aBFx+L~GFt zs>PV+pdp&>mGGI;ZwmDmYG?=DpqRyvxpthdE3JvW^%hj3Tj3TOF3X>cv=3zMtjSYb zPJIO$@sP$(fc4mh;boHC2%9}<3sSJ#OT&E-IZr9ap*9`8M8G*9E$bli~#9xu#X0U%HBDi|6|i|ebW3>r%h*Nx@H;>OpK zYU!tSJ)vJ6@iNZ-d#J==^|wlaFf(95Ss&|NZrm50-Y+qF=mp9;*2Xh`cAv)D@7m5` zFRPqvx{Od}|1Prn85JyOS2-nI6YQq`*=3O%OcB>~tzKf7rO=hjK;DJkfums8^AINe zEI_{gF09B>^pm7x6*c<*;AOk;M5xN`U7nzzFRL)!}a+4mk}zI(LErolb95fLga!|<;!jN9%U zd|q=}bv901Tuk?KlZ!WuXzSexCTCz@w8t!Z#ylGB*w>x*K~Lu!*w$KVG0lM|3*UhI8g5cyNDLC}B|7CL?lI@|yw*iCDM{euw?dLf5WJ zxUT5}=6<2jk^powO88m^n7{m|35eL$ynvqR!`W8We^2-$8^<7#vBm2vuw?dm-wMI6 zKakH~an-Bbh{x`$f35A;eFvXu-8b?k)21W2dXuW@?#%;iemv(d0!MBej6?>QU2$@< zUUKzs%+?PF+)mZ|O#3j`VS0QcLUjwMS6A}{RLo#HUHT1SIGeXX6OU_i7LXf9-2wQc z!6a2n*J0_3oC0~QTP}?$k%UYes zQn?kWIsVu>>LO!K--WeDHwQC$eMreSd`l!*mMx5Phd>u2f!SobKyqQN*``!%X?J*f zFAiO5kot&LDcHHt{@#|o5>)1~e0=0RBVCISxD>ax8M4LiCoK$CnwWP!n}~3>e6|00 zo;+d=m^pih3JT>JB9{X0eI-(&oa~)4qWMQlX4PwAI*^+F*a~*yHtZ<4*UV;3>n_O9 zC>q(fwcLnH9`KhCEmd#t-w%FF<36OjKGc;6GR`pAWy%7dOGxSyfm#*msN}_gUcXy8 zcK<00Ky_PTiiwG;n*4Sc0YY|OWPLAD)&|>U1106IAEuik)c7ScQ9IU4OQngYl$EsV z+812Q%is;dRy#RUQR|T*_l>d!>?kL8N-KkEY!rZzWl;~_w*n4j_LugTJ)sTT1nozT z@Bv-DO~m5)olec9p#8-__yAj#r~B5IsqG;a#*O86?|*BmK3^f@q*289klTq}$xDdeSP?7%XI!qFHS!k53ObIZ zlc62qj9-e64EMW&m$K01yaAo}#+Pf%I=U|YG`HDtwYo!FpqY0k+?HGT9^@hWF&jD= z^!9QnR`}lBPAPAWyu;yBOe;i}RMDFB(TV47;as8h;j6zJ%pc*&>^!FBWw<>*l@YHN zR{A>SJ2%T5cQ!9O{=99Nz?4Mje7SA!Us;Viy{fonQ|kRJF7*ra(;xHSd+nC>a)L!C z!B(X8ltlv&fNI?J08zk}G;#9?vfX)_f?}>)HTQ(blea8}xVlrTgqyiL3U+P5Mheux zVUCv`XC+`bEm^%{cRyZ$7C5^t3XTXKL%A1U99R;3E0e>Yt!r!8R36QqFyehUt?=kY zfQ1cf=Hk?kcxe#17Wr})<9pW~L{KUOQB}s{1tf5gk zdBp4tcwnP8BE=`H(S5;IQQfPu~}a2%W4g`*};po|*R5-hjc#tOW_Mu{$s6Fx`hLtAh^UXXdYl|KdA zm?%K!f?d~59%Ec3JQ)(|1N6%fa^=Ho`kCaj_T>O+aR805HUkp31`zTig26rC^@rvNT$qTRn}1kh|0CdM znW$uKfV0pX$y$q7R(%tlp-wQBM%Iss$~>n+*-t=?p~xIN<*iMO@f2(H*5r1jEn)&u ztBI+r?Cf>RsR^3(RHt^`)lxNftpd4JCgJh>iTDBTWy+5=s~3;%J66hTQ9TC!$c7 z-b6Qe>f^}~5^7`>+>w z2*!EySVz1QNRo8Ma%!-7Ykq1=y&p6+OExcq>&4IE@{?fN6LMPbHq8Fk`AC3dhNDBc z)Usnx%M@au-BU`NEOxMS`n+s$YD3;61I*mRPqLE#T<|V(lG9%7SrEGewqzWEio{qP zBzzc-!NFG4F+}U|+ulDq?80 zXvBEmFG(H3P`Ldu4HFvk-;bcMZMsa(Xm^Gm^^s*{5;Buf4!4GGxxNOiZAnB$Bfr~Z z8!cewA-P!^f~LVW7C?w})&U&mkQ$SN7;W?uby@!2eb+-hQ#coCxI@~DoXGtLI7v+W%WopD{^ZiyGpgjA`aK-yGUMl3M(QQAAGj+!w@$(^AwG3Jz(I|E!+fT*;}u3=>^}0Ki!#xb5&6#t;La*F9k}BKSy9U;2+Qw{W$Pt zrzfx}RIEMdtI3H2Kc{eN?0vzV+PH=%ed<>N^~DrAPtS$?L|8X740`id(VhI|2<#`( z$Tqa`?2NRN@6?MQ$GdoD(QpH`rBr9X>q?$rVpuaSe1y~3{n60>roI*bH} z1`Hc&p94JD%ph@<`Mkf_)9*33W~IRP%HaXn1{BP>;9PCCdP$}fo60$+T`jZHqL1N z`a^2UoKIhAU#9(QnkT1fz`m7{|)=KE_eAQyd5#Dp;#i8{b&H6aAn6 z$H(B{YR$lfU_hki;Qjw3McBxAd3pY?F~Ls8#=)JwhXjEG&Bn+5zx~rxbw5GPSHhKF z6@~bzn0L)|oyZ*KTUH3+N-WhbS0TzAqf_H9R#Q2Zg<*(l231<))J4*I`8I?~F|O5? zdNErabr=)pWoAYVksCXoE7v0LJAVVV{|e4N2;Z1Hvf%r@jxE(%c?JD?$9h z<&AC+QZCi|mc^B9HEyAsY!3lvdSF60B?U-&Z7Lwdoq&U$MV`Sx`n-G{6vq&Qk3|S( zg%F$FGq<7I?JJ~mV-=38Gc~cF`b^p_XAk0`k`Cq>I2JQAOF{?XnG@;4JCh){L1Lq8 zo5rGKPanJB6j$J3D+B&D19Ur4{q^zvw=h4N0j7_nM5??Y(lb`%X4yjc-zW`9P-8_B zXB|P<&I4_9f>@)-G_F!qfKkH!bwPB*LW&p4Yo2c67?V04<1ochRJs=KM*SYaFye@Q z3XD37sV0+Hj!h6h##gM%!xJG7Y==+wM`YtHdYg&8FkF8WrGY+#EL|9doTexxgF+n` z7JVQFx({=pv;F(XXtYX@Xsk@AYEJ@Z0FVGG!_5RcvTX1BPz>yp6dl$6G#SY20)-s^ znvg!IpVouaa11RJ3LSNZQu3>HeroJ%In0Ti0wTN8N)yEJQ@%9h4DN|E9^?e`Pr<@& z<(Aq6Zx~Yb6q%r|xdh724t&~+)-Wti9=pdO!iDjX??ESSh!;T($X=SCum*L5-YXwD zyKK%fH=kyLk0?X0dspuup9EM@X}qX2{l?EFI82<5a%|T*l;kALH5ZN&id^z5ooOB$ z6Ve{;r9qDiX|pDlX!S0vlZ6bIV)19yZ*Y54kkoji#ipw}0xYpiwh{~kb~`qyPgPO@ zx4>U(OCYAXr-mV572WLbD5LJY++GEXD(8Y9Qaad3upkEyOg0b)d^>Ad2n zB+%8XmiRi31I+X?W7c^XGeP$8`OSeWXDqUEY^z|xMvh|F%OhUyXY#BH42$;i-QU1# z+%k^3SZh4)nmo*O^n1x_A*w+8PIrUU(Bp25_uxDPLab9grEtjY$e+&F;Di!-z>gRsNXYS`u5w33YLgcHNkp~5B!NWG1Me*^-;$aXD zjsFN+!@@o{l+|^Q_%y5| zj>v_q)z-nGxXiBChj1?tv;`MHnp&1f$71YqYQJ;W{V2bgzzsjU;Kr$$aHg+H*}-b> z*0JbCwF%XDalKz&VC9u6~Gi@QuWbD^8O=?OvJOKkXul~asvl?j$lc@f((e?l4 zgSHG_Lq`0|w%fGy*H;afY)+D!sgqs4hHU?J9VS<*L&fX(ewWBrCT(gD{+(;<@f}~$ z5jhOYL?(OZWBN!dZlQ4lFBr6^cXG1&F5TnHS>()}q6KqY)rHvVj8kXr$ zF|)2Plh-;|*#%=D`B{GIg6J@#IaXm?BT$`XcmTj09zm9v=4&3uE*OfLh= zXfm>`4$b)`O}X~QQb1=6XWDgpy?nttJHQ}y@8qJnIcwH+NzX^?QDY=n2=_=Y2Exeg z@HblCrbyNgAG%VN&oYq3T%Bp~%hk6=lSre`^-|aA9%H--#u3F1$K30B4*6~v991UQl)lvr}4mp7#<$3C8Pnyy58~e z|K};ha#p=g-nlg2evzGh;yBhpC6exvZE`K@J^lKhc{$yy^#MUDyH5Jw;Kzmlv}Vym z3?L>8@?y0*aYDR6LUMAn0(l@hAd}lnv0AzLA)uikIk{Q~MIfpmlie$@T7$$P@cu*b zv}Q^|$U-IW?_;$-%0T4&hvG}8=7&&e-BW-VflRi)z-sMKhVX=h)I%E zF#lF4o+|cj=Fm^HF;Dw)_%NL2v^7=3a6=kTP=K|Z+>b;}f>MgqV z1n{kn>OO}&-4PYCGx0&v2vr{=u1koFCj1tXI8+G|h4>&HMX-tuQJq+j8QsZHJp4hP zOh^I%gB{a(01`y{3Z*$Hj_C{iJMsH$n@&Ea@^^KFkDvIavVHz+1rU2}qE|2A6ImL6 z`GkqTkQS|Ae6cs-Jq+98Kv8I^k|nh0T_P6>+%Ws!W)vS$g^KY}eFvdCAkx0+2XzeI z<#s-8OZ5_kVz5|uZvs*mpKxb;uK>u6Wts?KK~GrFmj^^tsh2u#<}DGqByp}dBTqrl zGAQv+^7DR7btq-1LJ)cA1cE3fdICl4oU+}&d||z7Ter0O;jgq6&^2L}-LiF6nprq0 z3T-z~iskayh6QYAImVbVcBqg!?uwc$PQ#!PU#5qX*6|}y&B`tI;#fSO)&iF6Jz`rf5pVl zTd=P;=y)6XsoYDdEc!=eEsV-&RS2q4zcPl5B7?{W%;mkmY2+3rhK=4fFIeFiD?|@@ zxGz^11(T7@gTupKA6$RA>QdC_QLw+r;1Ia~>hoVUISyC9t*D0N^4Cx;Q&FvQ8dEiZ z^oa?Jo^g*$g-WejDDk`+gdiHgAR0u-88GmMyV*nj3`289#dAi`p)v!6*tG>4yuf=o zqk+)y4OEXbv{Is3u%jgs0Kw2@LGUK9ZnAq$FOc7v$ly>EUJzkYObSArZi(}DzkiCI zuq9X~mC5N-EklB%;TZDGWcQMSxIh9bluv)h)3z2WBQ)j0IwC{ z{Th*bP}tqalW0lL>ux*K7mABOo|^#p9HXigE4 z{MpYzPa7uTCuXJfq0N=xY|YASbGYs`(u={)!Or>hxER;=Yi8!dkI^xx^KaHh8KBQk z02=EI>+d+vK0zOL239t{_x=X%HJi=pOPE?bk9pYMpy$P-Q`aUa2aTNf!WiWk2Z<-5 z(FK+zXHbO*mwuC}Cqu9^BZMc;Xt7W!*#_zH+2$tr-JG^m+L!zxFXvpi#h{qiiwOUp zqWti?`M=c4lB>NojnSbv=!bn&8_>=s>Eq`7_-G^CXg^8^37VJL5>3Lxi!#639Tv;; z8LMWkaYm@VC;Ub<_G;W1*Wg9SHSmXyYnePzpnEtv+uWyOIq&eTK3ep-&EQED@to~+ zdg{3I2Az)0*n|TvvR-SGbj=!|j8_Y*#rFfM;d(~L6P5jmN2!r@iD#gN5F{~p?xedO zudCByTv3ja=D_F9Y@Msx?Ha~d1~=ntA#7n&iFa{xE-~j}4(itt5gcLRg!! z7^%vqbhd{KZzZ#H!%1;GS5Qq}+JbV9>>jz)sTZC5Ycn7-??_f$hzbK$jy-*cgKtDL zq3QI{pkud@|lxAj6qC-|`GVAO3YwKBRnyorbdS8gu zWsB8?Y?RHb=*mQhi+2jt`WjP333q6CvF|ha9U^P5{F7#j()K`)Z8iE|e&0&PdssZ%1{BI0#AhPO^8L*LYkg@&ORCjW6 z|E~%7PgkoWvdTGHIsI3${hvyb%s`NvPmG;Mf}N9-gHsZ~$;~asEiNU&!y(ScDaFnu z!Nw&__Wut-{_mpy^RI)GEm;hL0YtnosjT6GK6;l~9HLpG9Rn#ZR;8_v6s})^m;#pV z_XVbA)8WammA%uOx1U{ij;Fyt+F*J1aJM3mw}Q#X#8F|jimH0A_#fwS zln5jUi?iZ4REjjrHO;w;tkoPv>^36ZAw!H}{2LimyFntN;| zTA0RNi|+uaV%0D{x_&`LP#>gVD77~vtBD%*)1Ti}{p?GH5UhJRHGK@`uOv17{Pulz zYnpOAA5}aI%}#mSRsQ}rK!u~1{Bnm>(#Skd%|I{T4J{yvw{Q7<`94sE>p9h;sH2Ni z_VX#fYGd_^UVZul5oD1a{Ba_>N2hw|d?r!w!2uYDNmcnTOw>0(RwFVg|NY(U5?s$Z r(t~fj^KntGnGQRM^;DDtnVv7!m)-@0AVTKl=3wVQq^6cqkw*Mq$8I+} diff --git a/main.tex b/main.tex index 7bb451f..143e447 100644 --- a/main.tex +++ b/main.tex @@ -56,7 +56,11 @@ One major open problem for \scut{} is the best approximation ratio for planar gr \section{Literature Review} % Requirement: summarize previous research contributions and identify the gap or the specific problem +The seminal work of \cite{leighton_multicommodity_1999} starts this line of research. They studied multicommodity flow problem and proved a $O(\log n)$ flow-cut gap. They also developed $O(\log n)$ approximation algorithm for multicommodity flow problems, which can imply $O(\log n)$ approximation for \scut{} and $O(\log^2 n)$ approximation for \nonuscut{}. The technique is called region growing. They also discovered a lowerbound of $\Omega(\log n)$ via expanders. Note that any algorithm achieving the $O(\log n)$ flow cut gap implies an $O(\log^2 n)$ approximation for \nonuscut{}, but it is possible to approximate (non-uniform) \scut{} with better ratio. This paper showed that $O(\log^2 n)$ is the best ratio we can achieve using flow-cut gap. +For \nonuscut{} \citep{leighton_multicommodity_1999} only guarantees a $O(\log^2 n)$ approximation. This is further improved by \citep{Linial_London_Rabinovich_1995} and \citep{lognGapAumann98}. \cite{lognGapAumann98} applied metric embedding to \nonuscut{} and obtained a $O(\log n)$ approximation. The connections between metric embedding and \nonuscut{} is influential. \nonuscut{} can be formulated as an integer program. \citeauthor{lognGapAumann98} considered the metric relaxation of the IP. They observed that \nonuscut{} is polynomial time solvable for trees and more generally for all $\ell_1$ metrics. The $O(\log n)$ approximation follows from the $O(\log n)$ distortion in the metric embedding theorem. + +\citep{arora_expander_2004} and \citep{arora_osqrtlogn_2010} further improved the approximation ratio for \scut{} to $O(\sqrt{\log n})$ via semidefinite relaxation. This is currently the best approximation ratio for \scut{}. \section{The Research Design} % Requirement : Your research design may include exact details of your design and the information should be presented in coherent paragraphs: % Example: diff --git a/ref.bib b/ref.bib index 377f60b..cfdc7a6 100644 --- a/ref.bib +++ b/ref.bib @@ -1,20 +1,20 @@ @article{chalermsook_approximating_2024, - title = {Approximating {Sparsest} {Cut} in {Low}-{Treewidth} {Graphs} via {Combinatorial} {Diameter}}, - volume = {20}, - issn = {1549-6325, 1549-6333}, - url = {http://arxiv.org/abs/2111.06299}, - doi = {10.1145/3632623}, - number = {1}, - urldate = {2025-05-07}, - journal = {ACM Transactions on Algorithms}, - author = {Chalermsook, Parinya and Kaul, Matthias and Mnich, Matthias and Spoerhase, Joachim and Uniyal, Sumedha and Vaz, Daniel}, - month = jan, - year = {2024}, - note = {arXiv:2111.06299 [cs]}, - keywords = {Computer Science - Data Structures and Algorithms}, - pages = {1--20}, - annote = {Comment: 15 pages, 3 figures}, + title = {Approximating {Sparsest} {Cut} in {Low}-{Treewidth} {Graphs} via {Combinatorial} {Diameter}}, + volume = {20}, + issn = {1549-6325, 1549-6333}, + url = {http://arxiv.org/abs/2111.06299}, + doi = {10.1145/3632623}, + number = {1}, + urldate = {2025-05-07}, + journal = {ACM Transactions on Algorithms}, + author = {Chalermsook, Parinya and Kaul, Matthias and Mnich, Matthias and Spoerhase, Joachim and Uniyal, Sumedha and Vaz, Daniel}, + month = jan, + year = {2024}, + note = {arXiv:2111.06299 [cs]}, + keywords = {Computer Science - Data Structures and Algorithms}, + pages = {1--20}, + annote = {Comment: 15 pages, 3 figures} } @misc{sparsest_cut_notes, author = {Chekuri, Chandra}, @@ -26,160 +26,175 @@ } @article{hoory_expander_2006, - title = {Expander graphs and their applications}, - volume = {43}, - issn = {0273-0979}, - url = {http://www.ams.org/journal-getitem?pii=S0273-0979-06-01126-8}, - doi = {10.1090/S0273-0979-06-01126-8}, - language = {en}, - number = {04}, - urldate = {2025-05-09}, - journal = {Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society}, - author = {Hoory, Shlomo and Linial, Nathan and Wigderson, Avi}, - month = aug, - year = {2006}, - pages = {439--562}, + title = {Expander graphs and their applications}, + volume = {43}, + issn = {0273-0979}, + url = {http://www.ams.org/journal-getitem?pii=S0273-0979-06-01126-8}, + doi = {10.1090/S0273-0979-06-01126-8}, + language = {en}, + number = {04}, + urldate = {2025-05-09}, + journal = {Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society}, + author = {Hoory, Shlomo and Linial, Nathan and Wigderson, Avi}, + month = aug, + year = {2006}, + pages = {439--562} } @article{arora_osqrtlogn_2010, - title = {\${O}({\textbackslash}sqrt\{{\textbackslash}logn\})\$ {Approximation} to {SPARSEST} {CUT} in \${\textbackslash}tilde\{{O}\}(n{\textasciicircum}2)\$ {Time}}, - volume = {39}, - issn = {0097-5397, 1095-7111}, - url = {http://epubs.siam.org/doi/10.1137/080731049}, - doi = {10.1137/080731049}, - language = {en}, - number = {5}, - urldate = {2025-05-09}, - journal = {SIAM Journal on Computing}, - author = {Arora, Sanjeev and Hazan, Elad and Kale, Satyen}, - month = jan, - year = {2010}, - pages = {1748--1771}, + title = {\${O}({\textbackslash}sqrt\{{\textbackslash}logn\})\$ {Approximation} to {SPARSEST} {CUT} in \${\textbackslash}tilde\{{O}\}(n{\textasciicircum}2)\$ {Time}}, + volume = {39}, + issn = {0097-5397, 1095-7111}, + url = {http://epubs.siam.org/doi/10.1137/080731049}, + doi = {10.1137/080731049}, + language = {en}, + number = {5}, + urldate = {2025-05-09}, + journal = {SIAM Journal on Computing}, + author = {Arora, Sanjeev and Hazan, Elad and Kale, Satyen}, + month = jan, + year = {2010}, + pages = {1748--1771} } @misc{dorsi2024sparsestcuteigenvaluemultiplicities, - title={Sparsest cut and eigenvalue multiplicities on low degree Abelian Cayley graphs}, - author={Tommaso d'Orsi and Chris Jones and Jake Ruotolo and Salil Vadhan and Jiyu Zhang}, - year={2024}, - eprint={2412.17115}, - archivePrefix={arXiv}, - primaryClass={cs.DS}, - url={https://arxiv.org/abs/2412.17115}, + title = {Sparsest cut and eigenvalue multiplicities on low degree Abelian Cayley graphs}, + author = {Tommaso d'Orsi and Chris Jones and Jake Ruotolo and Salil Vadhan and Jiyu Zhang}, + year = {2024}, + eprint = {2412.17115}, + archiveprefix = {arXiv}, + primaryclass = {cs.DS}, + url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2412.17115} } @inproceedings{arora_expander_2004, - address = {New York, NY, USA}, - series = {{STOC} '04}, - title = {Expander flows, geometric embeddings and graph partitioning}, - isbn = {978-1-58113-852-8}, - url = {https://doi.org/10.1145/1007352.1007355}, - doi = {10.1145/1007352.1007355}, - abstract = {We give a O(√log n)-approximation algorithm for sparsest cut, balanced separator, and graph conductance problems. This improves the O(log n)-approximation of Leighton and Rao (1988). We use a well-known semidefinite relaxation with triangle inequality constraints. Central to our analysis is a geometric theorem about projections of point sets in Rd, whose proof makes essential use of a phenomenon called measure concentration. We also describe an interesting and natural "certificate" for a graph's expansion, by embedding an n-node expander in it with appropriate dilation and congestion. We call this an expander flow.}, - urldate = {2025-05-09}, - booktitle = {Proceedings of the thirty-sixth annual {ACM} symposium on {Theory} of computing}, - publisher = {Association for Computing Machinery}, - author = {Arora, Sanjeev and Rao, Satish and Vazirani, Umesh}, - month = jun, - year = {2004}, - pages = {222--231}, + address = {New York, NY, USA}, + series = {{STOC} '04}, + title = {Expander flows, geometric embeddings and graph partitioning}, + isbn = {978-1-58113-852-8}, + url = {https://doi.org/10.1145/1007352.1007355}, + doi = {10.1145/1007352.1007355}, + abstract = {We give a O(√log n)-approximation algorithm for sparsest cut, balanced separator, and graph conductance problems. This improves the O(log n)-approximation of Leighton and Rao (1988). We use a well-known semidefinite relaxation with triangle inequality constraints. Central to our analysis is a geometric theorem about projections of point sets in Rd, whose proof makes essential use of a phenomenon called measure concentration. We also describe an interesting and natural "certificate" for a graph's expansion, by embedding an n-node expander in it with appropriate dilation and congestion. We call this an expander flow.}, + urldate = {2025-05-09}, + booktitle = {Proceedings of the thirty-sixth annual {ACM} symposium on {Theory} of computing}, + publisher = {Association for Computing Machinery}, + author = {Arora, Sanjeev and Rao, Satish and Vazirani, Umesh}, + month = jun, + year = {2004}, + pages = {222--231} } @article{leighton_multicommodity_1999, - title = {Multicommodity max-flow min-cut theorems and their use in designing approximation algorithms}, - volume = {46}, - issn = {0004-5411}, - url = {https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/331524.331526}, - doi = {10.1145/331524.331526}, - number = {6}, - urldate = {2025-05-09}, - journal = {J. ACM}, - author = {Leighton, Tom and Rao, Satish}, - month = nov, - year = {1999}, - pages = {787--832}, + title = {Multicommodity max-flow min-cut theorems and their use in designing approximation algorithms}, + volume = {46}, + issn = {0004-5411}, + url = {https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/331524.331526}, + doi = {10.1145/331524.331526}, + number = {6}, + urldate = {2025-05-09}, + journal = {J. ACM}, + author = {Leighton, Tom and Rao, Satish}, + month = nov, + year = {1999}, + pages = {787--832} } @inproceedings{lee_genus_2010, - title = {Genus and the geometry of the cut graph: [extended abstract]}, - isbn = {978-0-89871-701-3 978-1-61197-307-5}, - shorttitle = {Genus and the geometry of the cut graph}, - url = {https://epubs.siam.org/doi/10.1137/1.9781611973075.18}, - doi = {10.1137/1.9781611973075.18}, - language = {en}, - urldate = {2025-05-07}, - booktitle = {Proceedings of the {Twenty}-{First} {Annual} {ACM}-{SIAM} {Symposium} on {Discrete} {Algorithms}}, - publisher = {Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics}, - author = {Lee, James R. and Sidiropoulos, Anastasios}, - month = jan, - year = {2010}, - pages = {193--201}, + title = {Genus and the geometry of the cut graph: [extended abstract]}, + isbn = {978-0-89871-701-3 978-1-61197-307-5}, + shorttitle = {Genus and the geometry of the cut graph}, + url = {https://epubs.siam.org/doi/10.1137/1.9781611973075.18}, + doi = {10.1137/1.9781611973075.18}, + language = {en}, + urldate = {2025-05-07}, + booktitle = {Proceedings of the {Twenty}-{First} {Annual} {ACM}-{SIAM} {Symposium} on {Discrete} {Algorithms}}, + publisher = {Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics}, + author = {Lee, James R. and Sidiropoulos, Anastasios}, + month = jan, + year = {2010}, + pages = {193--201} } @misc{gupta2013sparsestcutboundedtreewidth, - title={Sparsest Cut on Bounded Treewidth Graphs: Algorithms and Hardness Results}, - author={Anupam Gupta and Kunal Talwar and David Witmer}, - year={2013}, - eprint={1305.1347}, - archivePrefix={arXiv}, - primaryClass={cs.DS}, - url={https://arxiv.org/abs/1305.1347}, + title = {Sparsest Cut on Bounded Treewidth Graphs: Algorithms and Hardness Results}, + author = {Anupam Gupta and Kunal Talwar and David Witmer}, + year = {2013}, + eprint = {1305.1347}, + archiveprefix = {arXiv}, + primaryclass = {cs.DS}, + url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1305.1347} } @article{Chalermsook_2024, - title={Approximating Sparsest Cut in Low-treewidth Graphs via Combinatorial Diameter}, - volume={20}, - ISSN={1549-6333}, - url={http://dx.doi.org/10.1145/3632623}, - DOI={10.1145/3632623}, - number={1}, - journal={ACM Transactions on Algorithms}, - publisher={Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)}, - author={Chalermsook, Parinya and Kaul, Matthias and Mnich, Matthias and Spoerhase, Joachim and Uniyal, Sumedha and Vaz, Daniel}, - year={2024}, - month=jan, pages={1–20} } + title = {Approximating Sparsest Cut in Low-treewidth Graphs via Combinatorial Diameter}, + volume = {20}, + issn = {1549-6333}, + url = {http://dx.doi.org/10.1145/3632623}, + doi = {10.1145/3632623}, + number = {1}, + journal = {ACM Transactions on Algorithms}, + publisher = {Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)}, + author = {Chalermsook, Parinya and Kaul, Matthias and Mnich, Matthias and Spoerhase, Joachim and Uniyal, Sumedha and Vaz, Daniel}, + year = {2024}, + month = jan, + pages = {1–20} +} @article{juliaJACMapxhard, -author = {Chuzhoy, Julia and Khanna, Sanjeev}, -title = {Polynomial flow-cut gaps and hardness of directed cut problems}, -year = {2009}, -issue_date = {April 2009}, -publisher = {Association for Computing Machinery}, -address = {New York, NY, USA}, -volume = {56}, -number = {2}, -issn = {0004-5411}, -url = {https://doi.org/10.1145/1502793.1502795}, -doi = {10.1145/1502793.1502795}, -journal = {J. ACM}, -month = apr, -articleno = {6}, -numpages = {28}, -keywords = {sparsest cut, hardness of approximation, Directed multicut} + author = {Chuzhoy, Julia and Khanna, Sanjeev}, + title = {Polynomial flow-cut gaps and hardness of directed cut problems}, + year = {2009}, + issue_date = {April 2009}, + publisher = {Association for Computing Machinery}, + address = {New York, NY, USA}, + volume = {56}, + number = {2}, + issn = {0004-5411}, + url = {https://doi.org/10.1145/1502793.1502795}, + doi = {10.1145/1502793.1502795}, + journal = {J. ACM}, + month = apr, + articleno = {6}, + numpages = {28}, + keywords = {sparsest cut, hardness of approximation, Directed multicut} } @inproceedings{chawla_hardness_2005, - title = {On the hardness of approximating {MULTICUT} and {SPARSEST}-{CUT}}, - url = {https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/1443081}, - doi = {10.1109/CCC.2005.20}, - abstract = {We show that the MULTICUT, SPARSEST-CUT, and MIN-2CNF/spl equiv/DELETION problems are NP-hard to approximate within every constant factor, assuming the unique games conjecture of Khot [STOC, 2002]. A quantitatively stronger version of the conjecture implies inapproximability factor of /spl Omega/(log log n).}, - urldate = {2025-05-09}, - booktitle = {20th {Annual} {IEEE} {Conference} on {Computational} {Complexity} ({CCC}'05)}, - author = {Chawla, S. and Krauthgamer, R. and Kumar, R. and Rabani, Y. and Sivakumar, D.}, - month = jun, - year = {2005}, - note = {ISSN: 1093-0159}, - keywords = {Approximation algorithms, Computer science, Costs, Linear programming, Mathematics}, - pages = {144--153}, + title = {On the hardness of approximating {MULTICUT} and {SPARSEST}-{CUT}}, + url = {https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/1443081}, + doi = {10.1109/CCC.2005.20}, + abstract = {We show that the MULTICUT, SPARSEST-CUT, and MIN-2CNF/spl equiv/DELETION problems are NP-hard to approximate within every constant factor, assuming the unique games conjecture of Khot [STOC, 2002]. A quantitatively stronger version of the conjecture implies inapproximability factor of /spl Omega/(log log n).}, + urldate = {2025-05-09}, + booktitle = {20th {Annual} {IEEE} {Conference} on {Computational} {Complexity} ({CCC}'05)}, + author = {Chawla, S. and Krauthgamer, R. and Kumar, R. and Rabani, Y. and Sivakumar, D.}, + month = jun, + year = {2005}, + note = {ISSN: 1093-0159}, + keywords = {Approximation algorithms, Computer science, Costs, Linear programming, Mathematics}, + pages = {144--153} } @inproceedings{chlamtac_approximating_2010, - address = {Berlin, Heidelberg}, - title = {Approximating {Sparsest} {Cut} in {Graphs} of {Bounded} {Treewidth}}, - isbn = {978-3-642-15369-3}, - doi = {10.1007/978-3-642-15369-3_10}, - language = {en}, - booktitle = {Approximation, {Randomization}, and {Combinatorial} {Optimization}. {Algorithms} and {Techniques}}, - publisher = {Springer}, - author = {Chlamtac, Eden and Krauthgamer, Robert and Raghavendra, Prasad}, - editor = {Serna, Maria and Shaltiel, Ronen and Jansen, Klaus and Rolim, José}, - year = {2010}, - keywords = {General Demand, Linear Programming Relaxation, Linear Programming Solution, Tree Decomposition, Vertex Cover}, - pages = {124--137}, + address = {Berlin, Heidelberg}, + title = {Approximating {Sparsest} {Cut} in {Graphs} of {Bounded} {Treewidth}}, + isbn = {978-3-642-15369-3}, + doi = {10.1007/978-3-642-15369-3_10}, + language = {en}, + booktitle = {Approximation, {Randomization}, and {Combinatorial} {Optimization}. {Algorithms} and {Techniques}}, + publisher = {Springer}, + author = {Chlamtac, Eden and Krauthgamer, Robert and Raghavendra, Prasad}, + editor = {Serna, Maria and Shaltiel, Ronen and Jansen, Klaus and Rolim, José}, + year = {2010}, + keywords = {General Demand, Linear Programming Relaxation, Linear Programming Solution, Tree Decomposition, Vertex Cover}, + pages = {124--137} } +@article{lognGapAumann98, + author = {Aumann, Yonatan and Rabani, Yuval}, + title = {An O(log k) Approximate Min-Cut Max-Flow Theorem and Approximation Algorithm}, + journal = {SIAM Journal on Computing}, + volume = {27}, + number = {1}, + pages = {291-301}, + year = {1998}, + doi = {10.1137/S0097539794285983}, + url = {https://doi.org/10.1137/S0097539794285983}, + eprint = {https://doi.org/10.1137/S0097539794285983}, +} +@article{Linial_London_Rabinovich_1995, title={The geometry of graphs and some of its algorithmic applications}, volume={15}, rights={http://www.springer.com/tdm}, ISSN={0209-9683, 1439-6912}, url={http://link.springer.com/10.1007/BF01200757}, DOI={10.1007/BF01200757}, number={2}, journal={Combinatorica}, author={Linial, Nathan and London, Eran and Rabinovich, Yuri}, year={1995}, month=jun, pages={215–245}, language={en} }